Jury Reaches Verdict in Karen Read Trial After Hung Jury in First Trial

THND Staff, June 18, 2025, 11:30 PM (ET)

The much-followed Karen Read trial ended Wednesday as jurors delivered their long-awaited verdict in Dedham, Massachusetts. This second criminal trial—following a mistrial in July 2024—brought renewed legal drama in the death of Boston police officer John O’Keefe during a 2022 blizzard.

Charged with second-degree murder, manslaughter while intoxicated, and leaving the scene, Read faced a jury of twelve people after a month of emotionally charged testimony. Prosecutors depicted a scorned and drunk Read who struck O’Keefe with her SUV, leaving him to die in the snow. They presented forensic and expert evidence to back their claims, while defense attorneys portrayed a schemed conspiracy. They argued no collision occurred, suggesting O’Keefe was beaten or attacked by a dog and then abandoned by others—but not by Read.

A key twist this time was that the lead investigator from the first trial was dismissed after sending derogatory messages about Read. The retrial also featured new attorneys on both sides. Defense counsel notably highlighted the alleged conspiracy and expert support arguing there was “no collision.” Prosecutors countered hotly, emphasizing eyewitness memories of Read saying, “I hit him,” and moments where she acknowledged potential impact in televised interviews.

Jurors debated for around 20 hours over four days, wrestling again with complex charges—especially manslaughter, which had stalled them the first time. Their verdict, unveiled today, could mean anything from full acquittal to conviction on all counts or even a partial ruling—leaving sentencing or further legal battles ahead.

Regardless, the conclusion of the Karen Read trial marks the end of a legal saga that captured public attention with its mixture of tragedy, corruption claims, and courtroom suspense. The community now awaits the judge’s next steps—whatever they may be.